OpenAthena argues that a post-training data commons does not exist. This article lays out a data engineering roadmap for AI Agent teams: record task trajectories, classify failure causes, and use synthetic data to fill long-tail gaps.
Post-training data sounds like public infrastructure that teams could jointly build, download, and reuse.
But OpenAthena makes a direct claim in its article, There is no posttraining data commons: no shareable post-training data commons currently exists. When the article reached the Hacker News front page, the page showed 42 points and 10 comments.
This is not the release of a new model, tool, or benchmark. It is more of an industry checkup. The article covers instruction tuning, preference alignment, reinforcement learning, and model distillation, but it also asks a more practical question: where is the post-training data gap for AI Agent teams?
My answer is that the gap is not more question-and-answer pairs. It is high-quality task trajectories that include tool state, failure causes, and acceptance criteria.
Why the data commons is a false premise
Code repositories can be shared openly. Images, papers, and web pages can also enter public datasets such as Common Crawl.
Post-training data is different. It is often not an isolated sample, but the product of a particular set of behavioral standards and business constraints.
Consider the same customer request:
{
"instruction": "处理这封退款邮件",
"context": "订单金额超过 200 美元,且客户提供了有效订单号",
"response": "符合退款条件,可以批准退款。"
}
At another company, the rules may be the opposite: amounts above $200 require supervisor approval, and a missing order number means the customer must first supply additional documentation. Which answer counts as correct? Only the company that produced the data and its reviewers know.
Preference data is even more complicated. It records not just answers, but comparisons and human judgment standards. Is one response more concise, more helpful, or better aligned with the brand voice? Different annotators may reach different conclusions.
Reinforcement learning also requires a clear objective function, reward rules, and safety boundaries. Publishing a reward function does not mean every team can reproduce the same behavior.
For those reasons, post-training data is difficult to share in the way code or image assets are.
This does not mean data cannot be open sourced. It means being publicly available is not the same as being shareable, and neither guarantees that the data can be used for training. Licensing, privacy, business rules, annotation standards, and data lifecycle requirements all limit reuse.
Distillation is not a substitute for a data commons
Distillation is practical.
A stronger teacher model generates responses, and those responses train a smaller student model. The results are usually good. GitHub and Hugging Face are full of teacher-generated datasets.
But distillation mostly reproduces capabilities the teacher model has already demonstrated, not the full boundaries of those capabilities.
For ordinary question answering, distillation can copy tone, knowledge organization, and some reasoning patterns. For AI Agents, the complications multiply quickly.
An Agent task usually involves several stages:
- Understand the objective.
- Select a tool.
- Construct the arguments.
- Read the tool output.
- Revise the plan based on the results.
- Determine whether the task is complete.
A teacher model's final answer does not preserve the entire intermediate process.
If teams distill only the final outputs, a student model may learn to respond like an answer without learning why a tool was called or why the arguments changed. When it encounters a tool error, a missing field, or insufficient permissions, it may even continue fabricating results.
Failure samples are more valuable:
- Which step selected the wrong tool.
- Which argument conflicted with the task state.
- Which error recovery happened in time.
- Which response was fluent but failed the acceptance criteria.
These trajectories can transfer. Successful trajectories are generally easy to share, while failure causes tend to sit closest to internal business experience and are the hardest to standardize.
Distillation can therefore expand dataset size, but it cannot replace a post-training data commons. It copies the teacher model's output layer rather than its full decision process.
Synthetic data is not a free lunch
LLMs can generate training samples in bulk.
It is the cheapest and fastest option, and also the easiest to overestimate.
If model A generates data that is then used to train model B, whether the two models share a lineage or are closely related, the generated preferences get amplified. A small initial bias can become a systematic bias over several rounds of iteration.
The more direct risk is that models generate the kinds of answers they already know.
Synthetic data works well for tasks with consistent formats, explicit rules, and verifiable correctness. Examples include:
- Converting natural language into a fixed JSON Schema.
- Extracting fixed fields from structured records.
- Generating edge cases for classification tasks.
- Generating and verifying code in an executable environment.
For open-ended tasks, however, synthetic data often lacks the noise of the real world.
The usual problem with random synthesis is distribution. The generator covers common examples but misses rare inputs, conflicting instructions, and tool failures.
Rule-based generation offers more control. Templates and state machines, for example, can generate tool-call trajectories. The advantage is legal state transitions; the drawback is rigid behavior, since the model may learn only to follow the surface format.
Real task trajectories are more valuable because they include details such as users changing requirements mid-task, APIs returning dirty data, permissions being denied, and tools timing out. They are also expensive to collect and raise privacy and compliance concerns.
The best use of synthetic data is not to replace real data, but to fill the long tail within it.
How far open datasets can go
Open data is still useful. It just needs to be evaluated by training layer.
Public instruction datasets such as Alpaca, Dolly, and OpenHermes are suitable for early experiments in instruction following, response formatting, and basic conversational style. Their limitations are clear as well: mixed sources, some model-generated samples, and quality and licensing that must be checked case by case.
Preference datasets are useful for training models on which response they prefer. But preference labels depend heavily on the annotator profile. A concise explanation that a coding assistant prefers may not suit beginners, while a response that general annotators find helpful may omit specialized safety requirements.
Code data requires even more careful separation. Source code, issues, pull requests, and commit histories in a GitHub repository are not interchangeable training material.
Each provides something different:
- Code corpora: syntax, API usage, and implementation patterns.
- Issues: problem descriptions, reproduction details, and discussion context.
- Pull requests: proposed changes and code review signals.
- Commits: local changes made during development.
These open sources can support general capabilities and baseline experiments, but they are unlikely to fill an Agent team's business-specific post-training requirements.
Licensing imposes hard limits. Code may permit training but not redistribution, user logs may contain personal information, and customer service conversations may fall under commercial confidentiality restrictions.
Teams should therefore build a source inventory before downloading the largest corpus available: where the data came from, what the license covers, whether original records can be retained, and who validates quality.
Data engineering for AI Agent teams
The practical approach is to build data around failed tasks rather than build a corpus around models.
The first step is to define task acceptance criteria.
“Check the order status” is not a usable evaluation item. Teams need to specify which tool must be called, which fields are allowed, when execution should be refused, and what the final output must contain.
The second step is to record real trajectories.
At a minimum, preserve five categories of information:
任务目标
环境状态
工具调用与返回
中间决策或计划
最终结果与验收结果
The third step is to classify failures.
I usually split them into four categories:
- Task comprehension errors.
- Tool selection errors.
- Argument construction errors.
- Result interpretation errors.
Each error type requires different data. Tool selection errors need positive and negative examples. Argument errors need schema constraints. Result interpretation errors require validators and explicit labels.
The fourth step is to use synthetic data to fill the long tail, then validate it in real environments.
Generating 10,000 random order queries offers little value. A better approach is to identify the unusual distribution in production failures, construct boundary samples for those cases, and check in an executable environment whether the tool calls actually succeed.
The fifth step is to iterate on data and evaluation together.
Rerun the same task set after every model or tool update. Compare not only final answers, but also tool-call counts, argument error rates, invalid loop counts, and refusal accuracy.
This process does not require a massive data warehouse upfront. It is more like a continuously running data flywheel: failures enter the logs, the logs are classified and redacted, and the results become training or evaluation samples that the next release validates.
Editorial takeaways
The scarce resource in post-training is not the number of samples, but the supply of high-quality task trajectories. For a conventional chat model, an answer with a preference label can convey considerable information. For an AI Agent, tool state, failure causes, and acceptance criteria are all indispensable. Even if a data commons emerges, it may not be directly usable for Agents because environments, permissions, and risk boundaries differ across teams.
OpenAthena's article departs from the familiar narrative that data scale determines capability. It places the sharing problem in the post-training context: the data exists, but it is difficult to establish common, reusable standards. I expect partial sharing to emerge, with tool-call trajectories, Agent failure taxonomies, validation scripts, and evaluation environments proving more valuable than generic question-and-answer data. How public data can avoid exposing corporate strategy and security boundaries still has no simple answer.
Sources: